On North Duval Area (party end of Duval)
Hilton Key West Resort & Marina - ★★★★ - our review - customer reviews
Hyatt Key West - ★★★★ - our review - customer reviews
Ocean Key Resort - ★★★★ - our review - customer reviews
Pier House Resort and Caribbean Spa - ★★★★ - our review - customer reviews

On Central Duval (Duval shopping district)
Almond Tree Inn - ★★★★★ - our review - customer reviews
Crowne Plaza La Concha - ★★★★★ - our review - customer reviews
Duval House - ★★★ - our review - customer reviews
Key Lodge Inn and Suites - ★ - our review - customer reviews
Pegasus International - u - customer reviews

North Island Key West
Best Western Key Ambassador - ★★★ - our review - customer reviews
Coconut Mallory Resort & Marina - ★★★ - our review - customer reviews
Comfort Inn Key West - ★★ - our review - customer reviews
Courtyard by Marriott Key West on the Gulf - ★★ - our review - customer reviews
Courtyard by Marriott Key West Waterfront - ★★★ - our review - customer reviews
Days Inn Key West - ★★★★ - our review - customer reviews
Doubletree Grand Key Resort - ★★★★★ - our review - customer reviews
Fairfield Inn by Marriott Key West - ★★ - our review - customer reviews
Hampton Inn Key West - ★★ - our review - customer reviews
Holiday Inn Beachside Key West - ★★★★ - our review - customer reviews
Key West Travelodge and Suites - ★★★★★ - our review - customer reviews
Quality Inn Key West - ★★★★★ - our review - customer reviews
Radisson Hotel Key West - ★ - our review - customer reviews
Sheraton Suites Key West- ★ - our review - customer reviews
Southernmost Hotel - ★★★ - our review - customer reviews
Sunrise Suites Key West- u - customer reviews

Off Duval* and Other
Alexander Palms Court - u - customer reviews
Blue Skies Inn - u - our review - customer reviews
Budget Key West - ★★★★ - customer reviews
Chelsea House* - u - customer reviews
Eighteen Hundred Atlantic - ★ - our review - customer reviews
El Rancho Motel - ★★★ - customer reviews
Fleur de Key Guesthouse - u - customer reviews
Gardens Hotel* - ★★★★ - our review - customer reviews
Heron House* - ★★★★★ - our review - customer reviews
Island Place - u - our review - customer reviews
Key Lime Inn - ★★★★ - our review - customer reviews
La Mer & Dewey House* - ★★ - our review - customer reviews
Merlin Guesthouse* - ★★★★★ - our review - customer reviews
Pearl's Rainbow* - ★★★ - our review - customer reviews
Southernmost on the Beach* - ★★★ - our review - customer reviews
Sunset Key Guest Cottages - ★★★★★ - customer reviews
Westwinds Inn - u - customer reviews

View hotels on an interactive map here (link)

*Lodgings with an asterisk are located 2 or less blocks from Duval

★★★★★ = recommended
★★★★ = good
★★★ = average
★★ = not recommended
★= avoid
u = unrated and unreviewed